Paw Hub

Are harnesses bad for dogs' shoulders?

4 min read

Dog in a red harness bounding across grass

It's a fair question. A harness sits around the chest and shoulders, so it's natural to wonder whether it gets in the way of how your dog moves.

Researchers have measured it, and the answer is reassuring. Here is what they found, how it compares with the alternative, and how to make sure your dog's harness never holds them back.

Vizsla sitting front-on in a blue Y-shaped harness
A Y-shape: straps meet at the breastbone and run between the front legs.

What's the difference between a Y-shaped and a chest-strap harness?

Look at your dog from the front.

  • A chest-strap harness, also called "straight-front" or "Norwegian", has a strap running horizontally across the chest, in front of the shoulders.
  • A Y-shaped harness has a strap running down the breastbone and between the front legs. Seen from the front, it makes a Y with the neck straps.

The Y-shape has a particular advantage for a dog that pulls: its straps meet at the breastbone, which is exactly where a front clip needs to sit.

What the gait studies found

Researchers have filmed and measured dogs walking and trotting in harnesses, on treadmills and with motion capture (Lafuente et al., 2019, Veterinary Record; Pálya et al., 2022, PLoS ONE). The findings are consistent:

  1. Any harness changes movement slightly. The differences are measured in a few degrees of shoulder reach.
  2. Fit and the individual dog matter most. Pálya and colleagues concluded there is no single superior harness, only the best fit for each dog.
  3. Y-shaped and chest-strap designs come out best. A 2025 review of 21 studies concluded that chest-strap and Y-shaped harnesses are likely to be the least restrictive of the types studied (Cavalli & Protopopova, 2025).
Penne running across grass in a green Brecon harness
Every harness changes movement a little. Fit decides how much.

So are harnesses bad for dogs?

No. Put the numbers in proportion: the differences researchers measure are a few degrees of shoulder reach.

Now set that against the alternative for a dog that pulls. Researchers at Nottingham Trent found every collar they tested exerted enough pressure on a model neck to risk injury when pulled (Carter et al., 2020). Another study found pulling against a collar raised pressure inside the eye significantly, while a harness didn't (Pauli et al., 2006, JAAHA).

That is the real choice: a few degrees of shoulder swing, or force on the throat. The evidence clearly favours the harness. The full comparison is in Collar vs harness: what the vet research says.

Penne standing front-on in a green Brecon harness
The front ring has to sit at the breastbone, where the straps of the Y meet.

Why the Brecon is a Y-shape

The Brecon No-Pull Harness is a Y-shape for two reasons. It is one of the two designs the 2025 review found least restrictive. And it puts the front ring at the breastbone, where the straps meet, which is exactly where a front clip needs to sit to turn a pulling dog back towards you. A wide chest plate spreads the load across the chest.

The review's first choice for dogs that pull is a non-tightening front-clip harness, and that is the job the Brecon is built for.

If your dog doesn't pull, a front-clip harness may be more than you need. See Front-clip vs back-clip harness: which is better?

Dog seen from behind in a black Brecon harness in grass
Check the shoulders from behind as well as the front.

How to keep any harness out of your dog's way

Fit matters more than the brand on the label. A harness that has slipped sideways or ridden up will get in the way far more than any design difference.

  1. Measure where the strap sits. Measure the girth about 2.5cm behind the front legs, not around the widest part of the ribcage. See How to measure your dog for a harness (and why most people get the chest wrong).
  2. Fit it snugly. Allow two fingers under the straps, and no more. A loose harness shifts with every stride.
  3. Lock the sliders. Push them up into the housing so the straps can't creep.
  4. Check the armpits. The girth strap should sit about 2.5cm behind the front legs, not rub in the "armpit".
  5. Take it off at home. A walking harness is for walks.

Watch your dog move after a change of harness. Rubbing, hair loss, a shortened stride or reluctance to walk are signs to stop and speak to your vet. Signs your dog's harness doesn't fit: rubbing, slipping, escaping covers what to look for. If your dog does agility, works, is still growing or has had joint problems, ask your vet or a veterinary physiotherapist which design suits them best.

If you'd like a second opinion on fit, send a photo to barkbark@penneand.co.

Frequently asked questions

Are harnesses bad for dogs?

No. Any harness changes front-leg movement slightly, usually by a few degrees, and a 2025 review of 21 studies found Y-shaped and chest-strap designs are the least restrictive types studied. For a dog that pulls, a harness is far kinder than a collar, which research shows puts damaging pressure on the neck.

Do Y-shaped harnesses restrict shoulder movement?

Only slightly, like any harness. A 2025 review of 21 studies concluded that Y-shaped and chest-strap harnesses are likely to be the least restrictive designs studied. A snug fit, with the girth strap 2.5cm behind the front legs, keeps the straps clear of the shoulder.

Do front-clip harnesses affect a dog's gait?

Not in a way that outweighs the benefit for a dog that pulls. A 2025 review of 21 studies recommends non-tightening front-clip harnesses as the first choice for dogs that pull, as the best balance of control and comfort. Fit it snugly and keep the lead loose so the ring stays centred.

Should my dog wear a harness all the time?

No. Use it for walks and take it off at home. If you notice rubbing, a change in stride or reluctance to walk, take the harness off and speak to your vet.