Paw Hub

Do no-pull harnesses actually work?

5 min read

A walker crouching beside a German Shepherd in a red Brecon harness by a lake

Walk into any pet shop and you'll find a wall of harnesses promising to stop your dog pulling.

It is a big promise. In a survey of 2,531 UK and Irish owners, 82.7% said their dog pulled on the lead (Townsend et al., 2021). Most people reading this have a dog that pulls.

A front-clip harness won't do all the work for you, but the research is clear that it helps. Here is what the studies found, and what makes the difference between a harness that works and one that doesn't.

What is a no-pull harness?

"No-pull" isn't a regulated term. It is printed on very different designs. Researchers sort them into two broad kinds (Cavalli & Protopopova, 2025):

  • Front-clip harnesses. The lead attaches at the front, close to the breastbone. When the dog leans forward, the ring is designed to turn their chest back towards you, so pulling gets them nowhere in particular.
  • Tightening harnesses. These cinch around the chest or under the front legs when the dog pulls, making pulling uncomfortable.

The difference matters. The research favours the first kind clearly.

A walker striding through heather with a German Shepherd on the lead
The research points one way: a front clip that doesn't tighten.

Do no-pull harnesses actually work? The studies

Here are the studies worth knowing.

Johnson and Wynne, 2024. Researchers at Arizona State University walked 23 dogs for five minutes in each of four pieces of equipment, and measured the pulling with a strain gauge. Dogs pulled significantly more on a martingale collar than on a front-connection harness (Johnson & Wynne, 2024, PeerJ). It is direct evidence that a front-clip harness reduces pulling.

Shih et al., 2021. This study shows why the front clip matters. A team from the University of Queensland and the University of Lincoln tested 52 shelter dogs in a neck collar and in a chest harness. When food was the lure, dogs pulled harder in the chest harness (Shih et al., 2021, Frontiers in Veterinary Science).

Read together, the two studies tell you something useful. Any harness takes the pressure off the neck, but a harness that simply sits on the chest gives a dog something comfortable to lean into. A front clip turns that pull back towards you. That is why where the ring sits matters.

Cavalli and Protopopova, 2025. This review at the University of British Columbia gathered 21 studies on collars, harnesses and head collars. Its conclusion for dogs that pull: "besides training", first consider non-tightening front-clip harnesses. The authors say these offer better control without being as restrictive as tightening harnesses, martingale collars and head collars. Those, they say, should be a last resort (Cavalli & Protopopova, 2025).

Why not just use a collar?

Pulling is only half the story. The other half is your dog's neck. Researchers at Nottingham Trent tested seven collars and a slip lead on a model neck, at the kind of forces a pulling dog produces. Every one exerted enough pressure to risk injury, padded and wide collars included (Carter et al., 2020, Veterinary Record). Another study found that pulling against a collar raised pressure inside the eye significantly, while a harness didn't (Pauli et al., 2006, JAAHA).

So a no-pull harness protects your dog from the first walk. Even while your dog is still learning, any pull goes into the chest instead of the throat. We cover the full evidence in Collar vs harness: what the vet research says.

Are no-pull harnesses bad for dogs?

Not the right kind. The design is what matters.

Avoid tightening designs. The 2025 review lists harnesses that cinch around the chest when a dog pulls among the devices that may cause more discomfort. A no-pull harness should work by steering, not squeezing.

Fit it well. Any harness changes how a dog moves by a few degrees, and a snug fit keeps the straps clear of the shoulder. We explain the gait research in Are harnesses bad for dogs? Shoulder movement explained.

A front-clip harness is a tool that makes training easier, not a silver bullet. Use it while your dog learns and in busy places, and move the lead to a back ring once they walk nicely. Front-clip vs back-clip harness: which is better? covers that choice.

Penne looking at the camera in a red Richmond harness
Fit first. A loose harness can't do its job.

What actually makes a no-pull harness work

This next part comes from our customer team, who see the returns. The pattern is consistent.

When a guardian writes "it doesn't stop the pulling", the harness is nearly always loose. A loose harness lets the chest plate swing to one side, and the front ring can't turn the dog towards you. It just slides.

Four things make the difference:

  1. Measure at the strap line. Measure the girth about 2.5cm behind the front legs, where the strap actually sits, not around the widest part of the ribcage.
  2. Fit it snugly. Two fingers should fit under the straps, and no more.
  3. Lock the sliders. Push them up into the housing. Loose sliders let the straps creep during a walk.
  4. Train at the same time. Stop when the lead goes tight, carry on when it slackens. Our full method is in Stop, stand still, carry on: training a dog that pulls. It matches the advice from Dogs Trust.
Penne facing the camera, the front clip of his green Brecon harness in focus
We built the Brecon around a front clip, with a back ring for when the training is done.

Our view

We designed the Brecon No-Pull Harness around a front-of-chest clip, with a second ring on the back for when your dog no longer needs steering. It isn't designed to tighten. It has a wide chest plate, three points of adjustment and adjustable shoulder cuffs, so it can be fitted snugly. That design follows what the current evidence favours for dogs that pull.

It isn't a silver bullet: it works best alongside a few minutes of training on every walk. What it does is make loose-lead walking easier to teach, and take the strain off your dog's neck from the very first walk.

If you'd like help checking the fit, email a photo to barkbark@penneand.co. Or start with How to measure your dog for a harness (and why most people get the chest wrong).

Frequently asked questions

Do no-pull harnesses actually work?

Yes. A 2024 study found dogs pulled significantly less on a front-clip harness than on a martingale collar, and a 2025 review recommends non-tightening front-clip harnesses as the first option for dogs that pull. Used alongside simple training, they make loose-lead walking easier to teach.

Do dogs pull more in a harness than a collar?

Not in a front-clip harness. A 2024 study found dogs pulled significantly less in a front-clip harness than in a martingale collar. A harness that simply sits on the chest can give a dog something to lean into, which is why the front clip matters: it turns your dog back towards you.

Are no-pull harnesses cruel?

It depends on the design. A 2025 review lists tightening harnesses among the devices that may cause more discomfort, and recommends non-tightening front-clip harnesses instead. Any harness should fit snugly without rubbing. If you notice soreness, take it off and speak to your vet.

Why isn't my no-pull harness working?

Usually the fit. If the harness is loose, the chest plate shifts sideways and the front ring can't turn your dog towards you. Check two fingers fit under the straps, the girth strap sits 2.5cm behind the front legs and the sliders are locked.

Is a front-clip harness better than a collar for a dog that pulls?

For the neck, yes. A 2020 Nottingham Trent study found all seven collars tested exerted enough pressure on a model neck to risk injury when pulled. A front-clip harness moves that force to the chest.