Front-clip or back-clip harness?
Clip a lead to the top of a harness, and a pulling dog does what a sled dog does. It leans in and pulls.
Move the lead to a ring on the chest, and the same pull does something quite different. That is the whole idea behind the front-clip harness, and it is why we added a front ring to our Brecon Harness.
The suggestion came from Oli, a dog trainer we consulted while designing the Brecon. He told us that guardians dealing with pulling, lunging or early training needed a front attachment. We listened. Oli, thank you.
Here is how the two clip positions differ, what the research says, and how to choose.
What's the difference between a front-clip and a back-clip harness?
It comes down to where the lead attaches (Cavalli & Protopopova, 2025):
- Front-clip. The ring is at the front, close to the breastbone. Some manufacturers call these "no-pull" harnesses.
- Back-clip. The ring is on the back, close to the shoulders.
Back-clip harnesses are far more common. In a 2021 survey of UK and Irish owners, 43.1% reported using a back-connection harness, compared with 11.2% using a front-connection harness (Townsend et al., 2021).

How does a front-clip harness work?
When a dog in a front-clip harness pulls, the lead pulls on the front of their chest. The force is designed to turn their chest back towards you, rather than letting them lean their whole body weight forward. Pulling stops getting them anywhere in particular.
That is the theory. What has been measured?
- Less pulling than a collar. In a 2024 study of 23 dogs, dogs pulled significantly less on a front-connection harness than on a martingale collar (Johnson & Wynne, 2024, PeerJ).
- The researchers' first choice for pullers. A 2025 review of 21 studies recommended that, alongside training, owners of dogs that pull first consider a non-tightening front-clip harness (Cavalli & Protopopova, 2025).

The case for a back clip
A back clip has real advantages for the right dog.
- It's simpler. The lead stays above your dog, away from their legs, and rarely tangles.
- It suits dogs that don't pull. The 2025 review suggests back-clip harnesses, especially chest-strap or Y-shaped ones, for dogs that walk on a loose lead and for flat-faced breeds.
- It's a sensible "after" harness. Once your dog has learned to walk nicely, you may not need the steering a front ring gives you.
What a back clip doesn't do is discourage pulling. A dog that leans into it simply leans into the harness. In one 2021 study, 52 shelter dogs pulled harder in a chest harness than in a collar when food was on offer (Shih et al., 2021). That is exactly the problem the front clip solves.
Does a front-clip harness affect how my dog moves?
Any harness changes how a dog moves by a few degrees, and a snug fit keeps the straps clear of the shoulder. A 2025 review of 21 studies found Y-shaped and chest-strap harnesses are the least restrictive designs studied, and it recommends non-tightening front-clip harnesses as the first choice for dogs that pull. We go through the evidence in Are harnesses bad for dogs? Shoulder movement explained.
Oli described the front clip to us as a training and control tool, and that is the best way to use it. Clip at the front while your dog is learning and in challenging places, such as busy pavements, crowds or near livestock, and move to the back ring once your dog walks nicely.
Which should you choose? A quick guide
- Your dog pulls, lunges or is still learning: front-clip, fitted snugly, with training.
- Your dog walks on a loose lead: a back-clip harness or a flat collar is likely to be enough.
- Your dog is a flat-faced breed: a harness rather than a collar for the lead. Ask your vet which suits.
- You aren't sure: start with a front-clip and the training method in Stop, stand still, carry on: training a dog that pulls. You can always step down later. On a harness with both rings, stepping down just means moving the lead to the back.
Fit and safety: what makes a front clip work
A front ring only works if the harness is fitted correctly. Our customer team sees the returns, and "it doesn't stop him pulling" nearly always turns out to be fit.
- Put it on the right way round. If the chest and neck straps are reversed, the front ring won't sit on the chest. It becomes ineffective, and can be unsafe.
- The ring sits at the centre of the chest. If it swings round to one side as your dog walks, the harness is too loose.
- Two fingers under the straps. Snug, not tight.
- The girth strap sits about 2.5cm behind the front legs. Measure there too, not around the widest part of the ribcage.
- Push the sliders up into the housing so they lock and can't creep.
Keep the lead loose and fairly short. A front clip and a long or retractable lead are a recipe for tangled legs. The 120cm Richmond Lead is slightly shorter than standard, for closer control near roads and crowds.

Our view
The Brecon No-Pull Harness has both: a front D-loop on the chest and a rear D-ring on the back. Clip at the front while your dog is learning or in busy places, then move the lead to the back ring once your dog walks calmly. You don't need to buy a second harness to step down. It has a wide reinforced chest plate, three points of adjustment plus adjustable shoulder cuffs so you can get it snug, and an anti-pinch "One Click to Walkies™" fastening. It was reviewed and approved by two vets, Dr M. Ohanwe, DVM and Dr Hafiz Muaaz ur Rehman, DVM.
If your dog doesn't pull, you may not need a front clip at all. Our lighter Richmond Harness has a single back ring and an over-the-head Y-shape, made for relaxed everyday walks.
Unsure which suits your dog? Email barkbark@penneand.co with a photo and a line about how your dog walks.
Frequently asked questions
Is a front-clip or back-clip harness better?
It depends on your dog. A 2025 review of 21 studies recommends a non-tightening front-clip harness for dogs that pull, alongside training. For dogs that already walk on a loose lead, it suggests a back-clip harness, especially a chest-strap or Y-shaped design.
Does a front-clip harness stop pulling?
It reduces pulling. In a 2024 study, dogs pulled significantly less on a front-connection harness than on a martingale collar. It is a training aid rather than a silver bullet: fit it snugly and pair it with consistent training for the best results.
Why does my front-clip harness twist to the side?
Almost always because it's too loose. If the chest plate can shift, the ring slides round to the side instead of staying at the centre of the chest. Tighten it until two fingers fit under the straps, and lock the sliders.
Are front-clip harnesses bad for dogs?
No. Non-tightening front-clip harnesses are the 2025 review's first choice for dogs that pull, and they take the pressure off the neck that a collar puts there. Fit it snugly, keep the lead loose, and speak to your vet if you ever notice a change in how your dog walks.
Can I use a front-clip harness with a long lead?
It isn't ideal. A long or retractable lead gives slack that can tangle around your dog's front legs. A shorter fixed lead, such as our 120cm Richmond Lead, gives closer control.