Paw Hub

Why your no-pull harness isn't working yet

6 min read

Collie on a slack lead looking up at its owner

"It doesn't stop the pulling."

Our customer team hears that sentence most weeks. When we ask for a photo of the harness on the dog, the answer is nearly always in the picture: a girth strap hanging a few centimetres low, a chest plate sitting off to one side, a front ring pointing at the pavement instead of straight ahead.

The harness is not broken. It is loose. And a loose no-pull harness is, mechanically, just a harness.

Most dogs pull. You are not doing anything unusual

A survey of 2,531 UK and Irish dog owners found that 82.7% said their dog pulls on the lead (Townsend et al. 2021). If your dog pulls, you are in the large majority.

The welfare research points in one direction for dogs that pull. A 2025 review of 21 studies in the journal Animals concluded that non-tightening, front-clip harnesses offer a good balance between comfort and reducing pulling (Cavalli & Protopopova 2025). We cover that review properly in do no-pull harnesses actually work?.

A well-fitted front-clip harness takes away your dog's leverage, so every pull turns them back towards you. It is a tool that makes training work faster, not a silver bullet, and the training in the second half of this article is what makes the change stick.

A spaniel in a black Brecon harness with the lead on the front ring
Clip at the chest, and a pull turns the dog back towards you.

How does a front-clip harness reduce pulling?

The lead clips to a ring on the front of the chest, not on the back.

When your dog surges forward and the lead goes tight, the pull arrives at the front of his chest, slightly to one side. That gently turns his shoulders back towards you. With the lead on a back clip, he can lean straight into it instead. The Brecon has both rings: use the front one while he is learning. (More on that in front-clip vs back-clip harnesses.)

That turning effect depends entirely on one thing: the chest plate staying where it was put.

Black dog seen from above wearing a red harness
From above, the straps should sit evenly on both sides. If they don't, the ring can't stay at the front.

Why a loose harness stops the front ring working

Picture what happens when the girth strap has a few centimetres of slack.

  1. Your dog pulls. The lead goes tight on the front ring.
  2. Instead of turning the dog, the slack lets the whole chest plate slide round towards the side the lead is on.
  3. The front ring ends up near his shoulder or under his armpit.
  4. Now the pull runs straight back along his side, and he carries on forward. The turn never happens.

Our customer team sees the same picture in photo after photo: the ring has migrated to the side. Once the straps are tightened and the sliders locked, the ring stays at the front, and owners tell us the harness behaves quite differently.

A loose harness causes two other complaints we hear. The first is "he looks uncomfortable", because a shifting plate and wandering straps rub and catch under the front legs. The second is "he backed out of it". Both are covered in signs your dog's harness doesn't fit.

The four-point fit check

Do this indoors, before the walk, with your dog standing.

  1. Girth strap position. The strap around the body should sit about 2.5cm (one inch) behind the front legs. If it is further back, on the widest part of the ribs, the harness is likely too big or adjusted wrongly. Our guide to measuring your dog for a harness explains why.
  2. Two fingers, no more. You should be able to slide two fingers, flat, under each strap and no more. Snug, not tight.
  3. Chest plate centred. The plate should sit on the breastbone, with the front ring in the middle of the chest. Ask your dog to walk a few steps and check it stays there.
  4. Sliders locked. On the Brecon No-Pull Harness, push each adjustment slider up into its housing so it locks. A slider left loose will let the strap creep longer, a little on every pull, and after twenty minutes the harness you fitted at the door is a size bigger.

Recheck after the first five minutes of the walk. A dog that has just shaken himself or rolled may need a quick adjustment.

Owner and dog on a country path, the dog a few paces ahead
Fit gives you the leverage. Training does the rest.

If the fit is right and he still pulls

Good. Now the harness is doing its half of the job, and the rest is training. Our customer team gives every guardian the same routine:

  1. Clip a loose lead to the front ring. Not the back, not the collar. A tight lead from the start gives your dog nothing to learn.
  2. When the lead goes tight, stop. Stand still. Don't pull back, don't say anything.
  3. Wait for slack. The moment the lead softens, because he looks round, steps back or simply stops leaning, walk on.
  4. If he keeps pulling, turn and walk the other way. It resets the walk and puts you in charge of the direction again.
  5. Repeat. Many times. The first few walks will be slow. That is the training working.

The lesson your dog learns is simple: a tight lead means we stop, and a loose lead means we go. We go through it in detail, including what to do in the first fortnight, in stop, stand still, carry on: training a dog that pulls.

Lead length helps too. A shorter lead gives you quicker feedback. The Richmond Lead is 120cm, a little shorter than standard, which many guardians find easier for close control near roads and crowds.

Patience pays off hugely. A dog that has pulled for three years will not stop in three walks.

When it isn't the fit

If you have checked all four points, trained consistently for a few weeks and nothing has changed, look at the bigger picture:

  • Is the harness the right size? If you are tightening every strap to its limit and it still feels loose, it is probably a size too big. Re-measure at the strap line.
  • Is your dog new to the harness? Some dogs walk strangely, freeze or rush for the first few outings. See what normal looks like in week one.
  • Is something else going on? A sudden change in how your dog walks, or a dog that seems sore, is a question for your vet, not for a harness.

Send us a photo

If you are not sure whether your harness fits, email a side-on photo of your dog wearing it, plus a photo from the front, to barkbark@penneand.co. Our customer team will tell you which strap to adjust.

Frequently asked questions

Why does my dog still pull in a no-pull harness?

Usually because the harness is too loose. A no-pull harness works by turning your dog back towards you when the lead goes tight, and a loose harness lets the chest plate slide sideways instead. Tighten so two fingers fit under each strap, lock the sliders, and pair the harness with stop-and-wait training.

How tight should a no-pull harness be?

Snug enough that you can slide two fingers, flat, under each strap and no more. The girth strap should sit about 2.5cm behind the front legs, and the chest plate should stay centred on the breastbone while your dog walks.

Why does the front ring end up at the side of my dog's chest?

The straps have slack in them, so the chest plate rotates when your dog pulls. Tighten the girth and neck straps, check the sliders are locked, and re-measure if you are already at the end of the adjustment. A harness that is a size too big will always drift.

Does a front-clip harness stop pulling?

It reduces pulling, and it makes training much easier. A 2024 study found dogs pulled significantly less on a front-clip harness than on a martingale collar, and a 2025 review of 21 studies recommends non-tightening front-clip harnesses for dogs that pull. Pair it with consistent training for a lasting change.

Why does my dog's harness get looser during a walk?

Usually the adjustment sliders are not locked, so the webbing creeps a little with every pull. On the Brecon harness, push each slider up into its housing until it locks, and recheck the fit five minutes into the walk.